Arsenal Weigh £52m Swoop for German Starlet as Mikel Arteta Eyes Future-Ready Defensive Depth

The incident raises fresh questions about the consistency of VAR and how crucial decisions could shape Arsenal’s Premier League campaign.
The turning point came late in the second half when Gabriel bundled home the winning goal. Moments earlier, however, replays showed him raising his hand toward Newcastle defender Woltemade’s face during a tussle in the box.
Referee Jarred Gillett allowed play to continue, and VAR checked the incident but decided against recommending a review.
Former referee Keith Hackett didn’t hold back in his criticism.
“It’s violent conduct. Gabriel deliberately puts his hand in Woltemade’s face. That’s a red card all day long. If Gillett didn’t see it, then VAR should have stepped in.”
Hackett argued that the decision not only ignored the Laws of the Game but also gave Arsenal an unfair advantage at a pivotal stage of the match.
According to Hackett, the officials failed on two fronts:
Instead, Gabriel stayed on the pitch and went on to score the decisive goal. For Newcastle fans, it felt like a double blow: a missed red card and a match-winning strike from the same player.
Woltemade himself was left furious, gesturing to the officials after the clash. His protests were waved away, but the debate quickly exploded online.
On X (formerly Twitter), “Gabriel” and “VAR” trended within minutes of the final whistle.
For Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal, the three points were massive in their push to stay in the title race. But the manner of victory has sparked debate: should they even have been allowed to finish with 11 men?
A red card would not only have ruled Gabriel out of the remainder of the game but also suspended him for three matches — a huge blow to Arsenal’s defensive stability.
For Newcastle, the sense of injustice adds to a frustrating season in which decisions have often gone against them. Eddie Howe’s side remain mid-table, but incidents like this can sap morale.
This is not the first time VAR has been criticized this season. From mistaken offside lines to missed handballs, Premier League officials are under growing pressure to deliver consistency.
Hackett summed up the mood:
“VAR is supposed to correct clear and obvious errors. This was one. The fact nothing was done is a failure of the system.”
PGMOL, the referees’ governing body, has yet to issue a formal explanation, but another week of controversy will only fuel calls for reform.
With both clubs fighting for very different ambitions, refereeing decisions like this could prove decisive come the end of the season.
The Arsenal vs Newcastle clash will be remembered not just for Gabriel’s winning goal but for the controversy that surrounded it. Keith Hackett’s explosive claim that Gabriel should have been sent off has reignited debates over VAR’s effectiveness and fairness.
Whether fans see it as Arsenal’s luck or Newcastle’s misfortune, one thing is clear: VAR remains the Premier League’s most divisive talking point.
Comments
Post a Comment